Post by Pheobe Halliwell on Jun 1, 2006 13:35:54 GMT -5
1.01 Something Wicca This Way Comes
The morning after Phoebe says the incantation to give them their powers, she's sitting on the steps. Notice, she must have recieved Prue's power of telekinesis for a moment. As she's sitting, when it first pans into her, she's sitting very still, yet the liquid (assuming coffee ) is moving like it's being stirred by an invisible spoon.
When Piper makes the comment of "Ok, we'll try the group hug later" her watch is on her right wrist, yet when she goes to take her cooking test, it's on her left. Did the make-up department figure out one of her tattoos was easier to cover than the other? (Kimber)
In the attic when Jeremy bursts in, notice that TWO fireballs are thrown from his athame, yet only one lands to surround the girls. What happened to the other one? (Kimber)
The tree in front of Halliwell manor is completely bald the night they get their powers (we see jeremy standing there in the rain). The next morning when Piper leaves the tree has not just leaves but flowers. (Camila)
Source: Screen scene forum
After the door to the attic opened Phoebe is holding the torch to the floor. Nevertheless you can see the beam on the windows and the door fram. You can also see Phoebe and she is holding the torch still to the floor.
When you see Piper running up the steps of the Manor she is using a navy umbrella with light blue trim. Yet once inside the house, she hangs up a floral umbrella
Source: NitPickers.com
top
1.02 I've Got You Under My Skin
When Piper is at the church the First time and the pastor walks up to the car to talk you can clearly see she only has eyeshadow on her right eye and when she get out of the car both eyes have eyeshadow.
When Stepan is giving Phoebe the address of where to go when she wants to model. Just before he writes on the napkin you can see that the adress is already there so he pretends to write it.
Source: TVTome.com
top
1.03 Thank You For Not Morphing
Why didn't the shapeshifter morph his finger into a key to open the door to the attic. He did it with the house door so why not again? But then - crashing against the attic door was more dramatically.
Evil can't touch the Book of Shadows. However the shapeshifter not only touched but also grabbed it.
We also learn that the book doesn't leave the house. In this episode it actively refused to be carried outside. However, in 4.03 Hell hath no fury Paige had not problem throwing the book out of the window.
When Prue finds "Andy" in her house, there is a guy sitting in the kitchen in the background, most likely a crew member.
Source: TVTome.com
top
1.04 Dead Man Dating
While Piper is rushing to clean up the invitations for Prue's party, we see her picking up all the cards in her hand from a front shot, then as they get a shot from the back, the cards are still on the counter.
Piper opens the door of the car so that Marc can get in. Why did she do that? He should have been able to walk through the door.
When Marc gets into the car, you can see it move under his weight - but ghosts don't weigh anything!
When Marc is sitting on the sofa, talking to Piper, he shifts and the cushion visibly moves under him.
When Wong has Piper tied in the chair, he grabs the back of her hair with his left arm. In the first shot you can tell that his right arm, with the gun,is relaxed at his side. But in the next shot, his arm, and the gun, are steadily aimed at Piper.
When Phoebe copies the Chinese characters, she does a fairly good job of reproducing them. But she puts them the wrong way around.
Marc couldn't turn on the TV because his fingers went right through the TV set, yet he could manage to sit on the couch. (Angie)
When Marc is shot, there is no bullet hole in his clothes, and no blood.
Source: Charmed Interactive
Despite the fact that Phoebe was hired less than a minute ago, the lobby already features a pink, professionally-hand-painted poster advertising "Psychic Revelations" by "The Amazing Phoebe." There's even a glossy color eight-by-ten photo of Phoebe.
Source: TWOP.com
Prue asks who Susan Trudeau is, maybe a "sister"? The girls grew up with Andy, wouldn't Prue know exactly whether or not he has any siblings?
top
1.05 Dream Sorcerer
If Berman was in Prue's unconscious, how did he not know that she was a witch and anticipate that she was going to use her powers against him?
Source: Charmed The Power of Three
top
1.06 The Wedding From Hell
When the demons push the girls into the bedroom Prue drops her purse, then in the next shot she has it again. We see Elliot roll off the bed to pick up the knife next to Prue's purse - but Prue already has the purse back!
Look at the headline of the newspaper Prue is holding at the end. I think it's the San Francisco Gazette, and it says, "Police Doubt Fire Was Accidental". This is a prop from the movie Mrs. Doubtfire. That movie also takes place in San Francisco, and Robin Williams's character uses the second and third word of the headline to come up with a name at the last second.
Piper has to substitute for Chef Moore who left on short notice, despite the fact that he quit at the restaurant as established in 1x02.
This occurs because this episode was produced earlier and held back.
Source: TVTome.com
top
1.07 The Fourth Sister
When Kali appears while Phoebe is sleeping we see her in the mirror and along with Phoebe's bed. We do not however see Phoebe asleep in the bed. Instead the bed is empty and has been made.
Aviva leaves her sweater in the sun room but later we see it in the kitchen.
Source: Charmed Interactive
top
1.08 The Truth Is Out There And It Hurts
During the first murder, the victim's eyes do become white as the warlock kills him. But in the shot of his body laying on the ground after the sisters arrive at the scene, one can clearly see his irises. (When Phoebe is pumping Andy for information later in the episode Andy says that both of the victims eyes were completely white.) (Stephanie)
When the future warlock asks Prue about the girl she was standing next to the elevator with, Prue says "I don't remember" obviously a lie - but she's supposed to be under the influence of the Truth Spell
Source: Charmed Interactive
top
1.09 The Witch is Back
Melinda asks Matthew why he turned her in to the witchhunters when he knew that she would burn. However, if Melinda was executed during the Salem witch trials, which the date shown at the beginning of the episode leads us to believe, Melinda would not have been burned at the stake. Witches were executed by hanging during that period.
In the beginning when Prue lets Matthew out of the locket, her hand keeps moving from at her side to on her stomach when the shot changes.
Source: Charmed The Power of Three
Melinda was born in 1670 and died in 1692. However the Melinda Warren in this episode does not look like just 22.
top
1.10 Wicca envy
When the sisters are looking in the Book of Shadows, Phoebe asks if the relinquishing spell is reversable and Piper answers "It doesn't say". But if you look at the book carefully, you can see what's written: "This spell is to be used in dire emergency; not lightly, only by choice." and the next line says "This spell is irreversable". Since we can see it from far, how is it that Piper (who was close to the book) wasn't able to see it?
Source: TVTome.com
top
1.11 Feats of Clay
top
1.12 The Wendigo
In the beginning, when they were all in the hospital, and FBI Agent Fallon arrives, Andy introduces her to the Halliwell sisters, but he points to the wrong sister as he says their names.
Source: Charmed Interactive
top
1.13 From Fear to Eternity
When Andy bursts in on Prue in the shower there is no white in her hair but when Phoebe comes home the streak has suddenly materialised. It then vanishes for the rest of the episode.
Water spills on Phoebe's dress but it is amazingly dry.
When Phoebe is playing with her coin she picks it up and then spills the water - yet suddenly the good luck coin is gone.
If you look carefully you can see a big white spot covering Prue's tattoo when she is in the shower
When Prue is in the swimming pool her bra strap is white. When she finally gets out of the pool it has magically changed to a black one
When Phoebe is sitting there debating if she should lie or not lie. You can see that there is no water in the water bottle. Yet when she spills it, it is full of water. (Crimson)
Source: Charmed Interactive
Talking of the mailing list, the house number that we see in close-up next to Phoebe and Prue's names in the shop is not the same house number that is later established as being their address. I don't even think that it's the same one that we saw on the flyers that Leo puts up in "The Fourth Sister".
Source: TVTome.com
top
1.14 Secrets and Guys
top
1.15 Is There a Woogy in the House?
In "The Fourth Sister", Leo hangs up flyers of the "lost" Kit around the neighborhood, and we see that the Halliwell's address is 7571 Prescott Street, but in this episode, Phoebe mentions on the phone that their address is 1329 Prescott Street. Has the house suddenly decided to move of it's own accord?
When Prue and Piper have to spend the night outside, you notice that the previous night, Prue had a black chocker on. In the morning you can clearly see that Prue now has a delicate silver necklace, until you see Piper go and throw a brick in the window, when we flash back to Prue and she has the black choker on again. (Jo)
Source: Charmed Interactive
Piper is in the kitchen trying to make dinner. She puts her head in her hands and says something like "What did I do to deserve this?" Well if you look carefully, when Josh comes in, she takes her hands off of her face and it's clean. But, like a half a second later her entire face is covered with flour.
Source: Slip-ups.com
top
1.16 Which Prue Is It, Anyway?
When Prue leaves Piper and Phoebe downstairs to go up to the attic to cast the multiplying spell, we see Piper's hair down - but as soon as she and Phoebe run upstairs and see three Prues, Piper's hair is up in a ponytail.
Source: Charmed Interactive
Phoebe reads from the newspaper that the only thing found by Ms. Statler's body was a blue sweater. I thought there might also have been a time machine, since there's no way her body was discovered in time for the morning papers.
Source: TWOP.com
top
1.17 That '70s Episode
When the Halliwell's enter 'Buddies' you can see a woman with long brown hair, and a man wearing a strange shirt getting up to leave. But later when Phoebe comes running in, they are still in the cafe.
When Nick tells Piper that he knows she froze him, you can see a clock behind the girls. The time shown on the clock is 12:25 even though it is supposed to be noon.
As some might have noticed that there was a problem in casting. for instance, little Piper has blue eyes whereas Piper herself has brown eyes, and little Andy has brown eyes whilst adult Andy has greyish blue eyes- did their eye colour magically change while they were growing up or something? (Nisha)
Source: Charmed Interactive
The movie Jaws wouldn't open for another four months from the date featured in this episode.
Source: TWOP.com
top
1.18 When Bad Warlocks Go Good
The victim claims that she felt the knife on her skin, when we can see that it never touched her.
When Phoebe was looking for the water shut off valve at Quake, she was too wet - it looked if she had just come out of the shower. Yet as soon as Piper arrived at Quake, Phoebe, along with her clothes, were well-dried.
Source: Charmed Interactive
top
1.19 Blind sided
When Prue was running after the Grimlock and David, there were trees around the hole that the Grimlock opened, but when the Grimlock and David were gone, the trees had mysteriously vanished
Source: Charmed Interactive
When Phoebe finds the underground place where the two kidnapped boys are supposedly being kept, she has her black backpack on and she still has it as she leaves to go to the Manor to fetch Prue and Piper. However when it cuts to her climbing the steps to the Manor, she no longer has the backpack on. But once inside it magically re-appears on her back. Either Phoebe has a new power or somebody forgot to give her a bag
Source: NitPickers.com
top
1.20 The Power Of Two
When Prue drinks the death drink we see her drink the full glass but later we see some of the red liquid left over.
When Phoebe and Prue are unpacking the grocery bag at the end, we can see that Phoebe is holding a cotton bag. However in the next shot, she is holding a tampon tampax box, and just taking out the cotton bag from the packet. (Virginie)
Source: Charmed Interactive
top
1.21 Love hurts
We hear a lot that Leo can't heal the dead but when Piper uses his power to heal him he has been dead for a while. (Charmed loserkid)
In all the other episodes concerning a Dark Lighter his arrows are only lethal toWhite Lighters but in this episode Leo clearly states that the sisters can't touch the arrow because it is poisoned. (Bart)
Source: Charmed Interactive
top
1.22 Deja vu all over again
When Piper and Phoebe are in the kitchen talking, we see Phoebe's hair up in a bun, but as soon as they go out to see Prue, her hair is down and clipped with two barrettes.
If you look very closely, just after Andy dies you can see his throat moving.
At the end when Piper and Phoebe are in the kitchen talking, Piper is wearing a "cross" necklace. When they walk outside to talk to Prue, Piper is wearing a "butterfly" necklace. (Pamela)
The morning after Phoebe says the incantation to give them their powers, she's sitting on the steps. Notice, she must have recieved Prue's power of telekinesis for a moment. As she's sitting, when it first pans into her, she's sitting very still, yet the liquid (assuming coffee ) is moving like it's being stirred by an invisible spoon.
When Piper makes the comment of "Ok, we'll try the group hug later" her watch is on her right wrist, yet when she goes to take her cooking test, it's on her left. Did the make-up department figure out one of her tattoos was easier to cover than the other? (Kimber)
In the attic when Jeremy bursts in, notice that TWO fireballs are thrown from his athame, yet only one lands to surround the girls. What happened to the other one? (Kimber)
The tree in front of Halliwell manor is completely bald the night they get their powers (we see jeremy standing there in the rain). The next morning when Piper leaves the tree has not just leaves but flowers. (Camila)
Source: Screen scene forum
After the door to the attic opened Phoebe is holding the torch to the floor. Nevertheless you can see the beam on the windows and the door fram. You can also see Phoebe and she is holding the torch still to the floor.
When you see Piper running up the steps of the Manor she is using a navy umbrella with light blue trim. Yet once inside the house, she hangs up a floral umbrella
Source: NitPickers.com
top
1.02 I've Got You Under My Skin
When Piper is at the church the First time and the pastor walks up to the car to talk you can clearly see she only has eyeshadow on her right eye and when she get out of the car both eyes have eyeshadow.
When Stepan is giving Phoebe the address of where to go when she wants to model. Just before he writes on the napkin you can see that the adress is already there so he pretends to write it.
Source: TVTome.com
top
1.03 Thank You For Not Morphing
Why didn't the shapeshifter morph his finger into a key to open the door to the attic. He did it with the house door so why not again? But then - crashing against the attic door was more dramatically.
Evil can't touch the Book of Shadows. However the shapeshifter not only touched but also grabbed it.
We also learn that the book doesn't leave the house. In this episode it actively refused to be carried outside. However, in 4.03 Hell hath no fury Paige had not problem throwing the book out of the window.
When Prue finds "Andy" in her house, there is a guy sitting in the kitchen in the background, most likely a crew member.
Source: TVTome.com
top
1.04 Dead Man Dating
While Piper is rushing to clean up the invitations for Prue's party, we see her picking up all the cards in her hand from a front shot, then as they get a shot from the back, the cards are still on the counter.
Piper opens the door of the car so that Marc can get in. Why did she do that? He should have been able to walk through the door.
When Marc gets into the car, you can see it move under his weight - but ghosts don't weigh anything!
When Marc is sitting on the sofa, talking to Piper, he shifts and the cushion visibly moves under him.
When Wong has Piper tied in the chair, he grabs the back of her hair with his left arm. In the first shot you can tell that his right arm, with the gun,is relaxed at his side. But in the next shot, his arm, and the gun, are steadily aimed at Piper.
When Phoebe copies the Chinese characters, she does a fairly good job of reproducing them. But she puts them the wrong way around.
Marc couldn't turn on the TV because his fingers went right through the TV set, yet he could manage to sit on the couch. (Angie)
When Marc is shot, there is no bullet hole in his clothes, and no blood.
Source: Charmed Interactive
Despite the fact that Phoebe was hired less than a minute ago, the lobby already features a pink, professionally-hand-painted poster advertising "Psychic Revelations" by "The Amazing Phoebe." There's even a glossy color eight-by-ten photo of Phoebe.
Source: TWOP.com
Prue asks who Susan Trudeau is, maybe a "sister"? The girls grew up with Andy, wouldn't Prue know exactly whether or not he has any siblings?
top
1.05 Dream Sorcerer
If Berman was in Prue's unconscious, how did he not know that she was a witch and anticipate that she was going to use her powers against him?
Source: Charmed The Power of Three
top
1.06 The Wedding From Hell
When the demons push the girls into the bedroom Prue drops her purse, then in the next shot she has it again. We see Elliot roll off the bed to pick up the knife next to Prue's purse - but Prue already has the purse back!
Look at the headline of the newspaper Prue is holding at the end. I think it's the San Francisco Gazette, and it says, "Police Doubt Fire Was Accidental". This is a prop from the movie Mrs. Doubtfire. That movie also takes place in San Francisco, and Robin Williams's character uses the second and third word of the headline to come up with a name at the last second.
Piper has to substitute for Chef Moore who left on short notice, despite the fact that he quit at the restaurant as established in 1x02.
This occurs because this episode was produced earlier and held back.
Source: TVTome.com
top
1.07 The Fourth Sister
When Kali appears while Phoebe is sleeping we see her in the mirror and along with Phoebe's bed. We do not however see Phoebe asleep in the bed. Instead the bed is empty and has been made.
Aviva leaves her sweater in the sun room but later we see it in the kitchen.
Source: Charmed Interactive
top
1.08 The Truth Is Out There And It Hurts
During the first murder, the victim's eyes do become white as the warlock kills him. But in the shot of his body laying on the ground after the sisters arrive at the scene, one can clearly see his irises. (When Phoebe is pumping Andy for information later in the episode Andy says that both of the victims eyes were completely white.) (Stephanie)
When the future warlock asks Prue about the girl she was standing next to the elevator with, Prue says "I don't remember" obviously a lie - but she's supposed to be under the influence of the Truth Spell
Source: Charmed Interactive
top
1.09 The Witch is Back
Melinda asks Matthew why he turned her in to the witchhunters when he knew that she would burn. However, if Melinda was executed during the Salem witch trials, which the date shown at the beginning of the episode leads us to believe, Melinda would not have been burned at the stake. Witches were executed by hanging during that period.
In the beginning when Prue lets Matthew out of the locket, her hand keeps moving from at her side to on her stomach when the shot changes.
Source: Charmed The Power of Three
Melinda was born in 1670 and died in 1692. However the Melinda Warren in this episode does not look like just 22.
top
1.10 Wicca envy
When the sisters are looking in the Book of Shadows, Phoebe asks if the relinquishing spell is reversable and Piper answers "It doesn't say". But if you look at the book carefully, you can see what's written: "This spell is to be used in dire emergency; not lightly, only by choice." and the next line says "This spell is irreversable". Since we can see it from far, how is it that Piper (who was close to the book) wasn't able to see it?
Source: TVTome.com
top
1.11 Feats of Clay
top
1.12 The Wendigo
In the beginning, when they were all in the hospital, and FBI Agent Fallon arrives, Andy introduces her to the Halliwell sisters, but he points to the wrong sister as he says their names.
Source: Charmed Interactive
top
1.13 From Fear to Eternity
When Andy bursts in on Prue in the shower there is no white in her hair but when Phoebe comes home the streak has suddenly materialised. It then vanishes for the rest of the episode.
Water spills on Phoebe's dress but it is amazingly dry.
When Phoebe is playing with her coin she picks it up and then spills the water - yet suddenly the good luck coin is gone.
If you look carefully you can see a big white spot covering Prue's tattoo when she is in the shower
When Prue is in the swimming pool her bra strap is white. When she finally gets out of the pool it has magically changed to a black one
When Phoebe is sitting there debating if she should lie or not lie. You can see that there is no water in the water bottle. Yet when she spills it, it is full of water. (Crimson)
Source: Charmed Interactive
Talking of the mailing list, the house number that we see in close-up next to Phoebe and Prue's names in the shop is not the same house number that is later established as being their address. I don't even think that it's the same one that we saw on the flyers that Leo puts up in "The Fourth Sister".
Source: TVTome.com
top
1.14 Secrets and Guys
top
1.15 Is There a Woogy in the House?
In "The Fourth Sister", Leo hangs up flyers of the "lost" Kit around the neighborhood, and we see that the Halliwell's address is 7571 Prescott Street, but in this episode, Phoebe mentions on the phone that their address is 1329 Prescott Street. Has the house suddenly decided to move of it's own accord?
When Prue and Piper have to spend the night outside, you notice that the previous night, Prue had a black chocker on. In the morning you can clearly see that Prue now has a delicate silver necklace, until you see Piper go and throw a brick in the window, when we flash back to Prue and she has the black choker on again. (Jo)
Source: Charmed Interactive
Piper is in the kitchen trying to make dinner. She puts her head in her hands and says something like "What did I do to deserve this?" Well if you look carefully, when Josh comes in, she takes her hands off of her face and it's clean. But, like a half a second later her entire face is covered with flour.
Source: Slip-ups.com
top
1.16 Which Prue Is It, Anyway?
When Prue leaves Piper and Phoebe downstairs to go up to the attic to cast the multiplying spell, we see Piper's hair down - but as soon as she and Phoebe run upstairs and see three Prues, Piper's hair is up in a ponytail.
Source: Charmed Interactive
Phoebe reads from the newspaper that the only thing found by Ms. Statler's body was a blue sweater. I thought there might also have been a time machine, since there's no way her body was discovered in time for the morning papers.
Source: TWOP.com
top
1.17 That '70s Episode
When the Halliwell's enter 'Buddies' you can see a woman with long brown hair, and a man wearing a strange shirt getting up to leave. But later when Phoebe comes running in, they are still in the cafe.
When Nick tells Piper that he knows she froze him, you can see a clock behind the girls. The time shown on the clock is 12:25 even though it is supposed to be noon.
As some might have noticed that there was a problem in casting. for instance, little Piper has blue eyes whereas Piper herself has brown eyes, and little Andy has brown eyes whilst adult Andy has greyish blue eyes- did their eye colour magically change while they were growing up or something? (Nisha)
Source: Charmed Interactive
The movie Jaws wouldn't open for another four months from the date featured in this episode.
Source: TWOP.com
top
1.18 When Bad Warlocks Go Good
The victim claims that she felt the knife on her skin, when we can see that it never touched her.
When Phoebe was looking for the water shut off valve at Quake, she was too wet - it looked if she had just come out of the shower. Yet as soon as Piper arrived at Quake, Phoebe, along with her clothes, were well-dried.
Source: Charmed Interactive
top
1.19 Blind sided
When Prue was running after the Grimlock and David, there were trees around the hole that the Grimlock opened, but when the Grimlock and David were gone, the trees had mysteriously vanished
Source: Charmed Interactive
When Phoebe finds the underground place where the two kidnapped boys are supposedly being kept, she has her black backpack on and she still has it as she leaves to go to the Manor to fetch Prue and Piper. However when it cuts to her climbing the steps to the Manor, she no longer has the backpack on. But once inside it magically re-appears on her back. Either Phoebe has a new power or somebody forgot to give her a bag
Source: NitPickers.com
top
1.20 The Power Of Two
When Prue drinks the death drink we see her drink the full glass but later we see some of the red liquid left over.
When Phoebe and Prue are unpacking the grocery bag at the end, we can see that Phoebe is holding a cotton bag. However in the next shot, she is holding a tampon tampax box, and just taking out the cotton bag from the packet. (Virginie)
Source: Charmed Interactive
top
1.21 Love hurts
We hear a lot that Leo can't heal the dead but when Piper uses his power to heal him he has been dead for a while. (Charmed loserkid)
In all the other episodes concerning a Dark Lighter his arrows are only lethal toWhite Lighters but in this episode Leo clearly states that the sisters can't touch the arrow because it is poisoned. (Bart)
Source: Charmed Interactive
top
1.22 Deja vu all over again
When Piper and Phoebe are in the kitchen talking, we see Phoebe's hair up in a bun, but as soon as they go out to see Prue, her hair is down and clipped with two barrettes.
If you look very closely, just after Andy dies you can see his throat moving.
At the end when Piper and Phoebe are in the kitchen talking, Piper is wearing a "cross" necklace. When they walk outside to talk to Prue, Piper is wearing a "butterfly" necklace. (Pamela)